Editor's Note: This is the first story in a five-part series about clinical research at the University of Nebraska Medical Center. To learn more what clinical research is and the role it plays at UNMC, read the
introduction to this series.
OMAHA - Mechanic and medical researcher Dr. William Haire is approaching dangerous blood clots in the body somewhat like the way a street maintenance engineer approaches potholes in the road.
While the engineer wants to use as little patching material as possible to plug the holes in the road, Haire wants to use as little medicine as possible to control the clots that plug up blood vessels and can kill. The engineer's aim is to stretch the city's always-limited maintenance budget. Haire wants to make a good clot-busting drug, Coumadin, work even better by finding the lowest effective dose -- one that keeps harmful clots from forming, but prevents the bleeding complications that make the therapy tough to manage. Coumadin has a narrow therapeutic range. There's not much wiggle room between a dose that's helpful, and a dose that's harmful.
When he's not treating patients for the common medical conditions of deep-vein thrombosis (usually, clots in the leg) and pulmonary embolisms (a clot that affects the lungs), Haire can be found working in his garage restoring 1946-1948 Plymouth automobiles. Or, he might be designing album covers and stage props for local rock bands. These mechanical and artistic hobbies help him think about new ideas for practicing medicine.
"The body is nothing more than just a very, very complex machine. But it takes an artistic, kind of out of the box approach, to understand some of the subtle complexities of this machine," he said.
Haire's penchant for the complexities of blood clots won him a role in a National Institutes of Health study of the popular anticoagulant drug Coumadin. He's known nationally for his work with blood clots. The affable Haire wouldn't volunteer this information, but when asked he'll confirm that he's one of a very few University of Nebraska Medical Center researchers ever asked to write two guest editorials for the prestigious New England Journal of Medicine. Both were on blood clots, a passion of Haire's and a national health problem. About 500,000 Americans a year develop deep-vein thrombosis -- a blood clot in one of the body's large veins, usually in the leg. Pieces of these clots can break off and travel all the way to lungs and block that organ's tiny capillaries. That's called a pulmonary embolism, and can be fatal. About half the blood clots patients suffer are ideopathic, meaning doctors can't find a cause.
It’s these ideopathic blood clots that concern Haire and researchers at 60 other sites nationwide. Paul Ridker of Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston, principal investigator for the study, said he looked for the top scientists across the country when setting up the project.
"And obviously Bill was one of those people," Ridker said.
The PREVENT study, as it's called, is fairly simple and quite convenient for participants. Patients who have been on long-term anticoagulant therapy with Coumadin get to stay on the drug for free, at a lower dose the researchers hope proves effective. Blood testing is needed just once every two months, and the testing machine is portable so study participants need not leave their home or work.
Some of these ideopathic clots run in the family and can recur over a patient's lifetime. By joining the study, participants can help themselves avoid future clots, and perhaps be of aid to their families as well.
"So Grandpa may be helping to answer questions that will be helpful to grandson or granddaughter," Haire said.
That chance to help others helped motivate Robert Volz to join the Coumadin study.
"It appears there's very minimal risk for doing it, and yet the outcome could be very beneficial," Volz said.
Doctors diagnosed Volz, vice president for facilities at Ameritrade in Omaha, with a deep-vein thrombosis of the right leg after he had taken just a one-hour plane ride to Denver. After six months on the standard Coumadin treatment, Volz wondered what should be his next step for preventing a second blood clot -- especially since doctors couldn't exactly place the cause of his first one. His doctor said he didn't know the best long-term option -- but there was a study at UNMC trying to find out.
Taking his traditional Coumadin treatment, Volz had to drive from Ameritrade in west Omaha to UNMC in central Omaha first weekly, then monthly, for blood tests. Now on the Coumadin study, someone from the medical center drives out to Ameritrade. A finger prick and five minutes later, it's goodbye for another two months.
"That's as good as it gets," Volz said. "It's awfully nice where someone's coming to you."
Haire's assistant John Schneider, a first-year medical student, is often the one driving out and doing the finger-pricking. Besides the scientific knowledge, Schneider said, he's gaining important experience dealing with all kinds of patients. He works with everyone from vice presidents like Volz to blue-collar mechanics. It's a big leg up for medical school, he said.
"Being exposed to that, I think, has really benefited me," he said.
Looking at what doctors now understand about blood clots, and what they hope to learn, is fascinating stuff. Think of the body's blood vessels like a road network, Haire says. The body's natural processes have blood vessels breaking all the time, and quickly sealing up when the blood clots as it should. This is like roads developing potholes that the roving street maintenance crew quickly fills (well, maybe not as quickly in some cities as in others). Clots also form when the body's injured; say, by a cut. Clots keep you from losing a lot of blood because they plug the hole from which the blood is leaking. It's when the natural clotting process gets out of control that problems start to occur. Then, clots can form where there are no holes to plug -- again, most often deep in the veins of the leg.
Conditions like trauma, serious illness and pregnancy can all lead to these harmful blood clots. What doctors have found in the past five years is that patients who get a clot tend to be at risk for another clot. So now they need to figure out exactly what this risk is, and whether there's a dose of the anticoagulant drug Coumadin that can be used long-term to prevent more harmful clots, while still keeping the blood's beneficial clotting tendencies around. If the balance isn't kept just right, and a patient's blood doesn't clot readily enough, he can bleed too much -- which leads to organ damage, organ failure and even death.
"It's a problematic medicine in that it's effective, but it's difficult to safely control over a long term," Haire said.
That blood testing we've been talking about is to measure a patient's prothrombin time, which means the time it takes his or her blood to clot. The term's usually shortened to "pro time," and the value is measured in units that go up or down from 1.0, which is the average clotting time for a human. When doctors are treating a blood clot with Coumadin, they're usually aiming for a pro time of 2.0-3.0, which means the blood is clotting two to three times slower than normal. The Coumadin study at UNMC wants to see whether a pro time of 1.5 can still be effective. Maintaining that kind of a pro time requires less Coumadin, so patients stay farther away from the "knife edge," as Haire puts it, between the drug's helpful and harmful dosages.
Coumadin and other anticoagulants, by the way, are not blood thinners -- even though doctors and nurses sometimes call them that to keep things simple for patients. Such drugs don't thin the blood, that is, change its viscosity. In fact, Haire said, only with some rare conditions does the blood's viscosity change. And anticoagulants don't prevent clotting outright, they simply slow down the process so the body can get it under control. Clotting is out of control when a clot forms somewhere other than where the bleeding problem is.
"If you will, (treatment with anticoagulants) is like adding a governor to your engine to make sure the engine can't go too fast," Haire said.
There's a tendency to blame bleeding complications solely on Coumadin, but people who do so forget that in order to bleed, there needs to be a hole in some blood vessel. In most bleeding incidents with Coumadin patients, a condition unrelated to the drug caused the bleeding -- such as a duodenal ulcer, a colonic polyp, or a kidney stone. Say a kidney stone scratches a person's ureter, and the bleeding doesn't stop fast enough because the Coumadin he's taking has slowed the clotting. The patient sees blood in his urine, and blames it on the drug.
"But did the Coumadin cause the bleeding? No," Haire said.
But the bleeding's still a problem, especially in older patients who are at the most risk for blood clots. They often have underlying diseases and weaker organs, both related to aging, that make it less likely they'll survive losing a lot of blood. That makes it even more important to find a long-term dose of the drug that can stave off dangerous bleeding complications.
One notable aspect of the entire PREVENT study is the diversity of its participants. While many clinical studies consist mostly of white men, PREVENT has almost half women, and 19 percent minorities. Haire has plenty more room for volunteers in the Omaha program, and he'd be glad to take calls from interested people at (402) 559-7599.
"I'll take a hundred more next week," Haire said.
_____
This story originally appeared in
Nebraska StatePaper on July 23, 2001.